Commit c6acc450 by PLN (Algolia)

docs(gig): the third pass, and what d9 was actually doing

A conformance check run before the step that breaks conformance proves nothing
— the compaction moved 150 orbits and left 202 of their controls behind, and
the tool said '0 move' about a file that needed four.

Also records the answer to PLN's own d9 note: its attack was riding d12's
Ardour-learned level knob, and its mask shares d6's gate with no legal
alternative, because d9 has no button slot in the grid at all.
parent 1567a814
......@@ -197,6 +197,25 @@ Open, highest leverage first:
- [x] **Orbit compaction DONE** (f6be520) — 150 moves in 133 files, band {5,6,7} derived
from the family maps so a move is inaudible; d4 (bass) and d8 (percs) never touched.
7 orbits refused for carrying an explicit `# orbit N`.
- [x] **THIRD PASS: the controls follow the orbits** (ca21d6b) — compaction renames a `dN`
but does not move that orbit's knobs, so 202 controls in 84 files were left on the column
of an orbit that had moved away. The two tools are one job in two passes. Found by
accident: `ete_a_mauerpark` reported "0 move" right after the compaction and 4 the moment
something else made me re-plan it — **a conformance check run before the step that breaks
conformance proves nothing**. Re-plan now 0 across all 703; third full sweep, zero verdict
changes; the 17-track set re-validated after, all OK, pvlint 0 errors.
- [x] **`ete_a_mauerpark` d9 — PLN's "[confirm d9 effects]" answered.** d9 gets exactly ONE
knob in the grid (A5 = ^17) and drives four effects. `att` was on **^16 = A4 = d12's
Ardour-learned LEVEL knob**, so one knob moved an Ardour track gain AND d9's attack — the
CC77-goes-to-silence class. Moved to ^20, idle in this track, verified.
`lesliebus` on ^18 and `chorus` on ^19 borrow d10's and d11's fx knobs; both orbits are
undeclared here so they work, they are just not d9's.
- [ ] **STILL OPEN, and structural:** d9's `mask` rides **^58 = BT6 = d6's own gate**, and
d6 IS declared in this track — one button, two orbits. d9 has **no button slot at all**
in the grid, so there is no legal destination: this is gSel work, not a rename. pvlint
does not flag it because PV008 only looks at orbits 1-8.
- [x] **`sept1` "TODO fix to new controller" is already done** — 0 moves, 0 overflow, 0
FIXMEs after the remap. If it still feels wrong at the desk it is not a mapping problem.
- [x] **Both migrations verified against the baseline** — `silent-eval --seeded` re-run
over all 703 files after each, diffed per file against
`docs/2026-09-22-catalog-playability.tsv`: **zero verdict changes, twice**. 597 playable,
......
Markdown is supported
0% or
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment