I gave Spotify Studio's agent every stream since 2009 and asked it the question no friend will answer honestly. It built me a lab, ran a 16-year backtest on my discoveries, and the verdict was not the one I ordered.

Who starts the discovery: you, or the queue? Since 2012 only 5 to 15 percent of first plays begin with a deliberate choice.

First plays split by how they began: a deliberate choice (click, search, my own playlist) versus a track that continued from the previous one. Since 2012 they have been 5 to 15 percent. I have not been discovering music; autoplay has been discovering music at me.

One in five. The queue throws a hundred doors at me a year and I walk back through five of them. But here is the thing: which five is not random, and that is where my defence begins.

My listening sessions are not shuffles; they are deliberate journeys through genre space. Someone is steering. It is just not the person clicking.

My taste is a real, compact, portable object. It has a shape. It is not a mood board; it is a fingerprint.

35,144 dots, each one an artist.

Another time.

The fix has a name and a cron schedule.

## So does it suck?

The humbling part is not that I have no taste. It is that I have a strong taste and a weak will.

The taste is provably mine: sticky, describable, consistent across the whole record. The discovery pipeline, though, has been running me since 2012, and I have been signing the output as "my music". The backtest caught me outsourcing curiosity and calling it identity.

Here is the verdict I ended up with, and it is not the one I ordered when I loaded the export files.
